Get extra lift from AOPA. Start your free membership trial today! Click here

WX Watch: Winter storm Avery

Scoping out a November nor’easter

Gordon Lightfoot’s song The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald mentions a November Great Lakes storm it calls “the witch of November…with gales that come early,” complete with “slashing” gales and freezing rain.
P&E February 2019
Zoomed image
The system beganwith lows over the Midwest and the Southeast Coast on November 14 (left). The high over New England sent cold air south, sinking as it went. An upper-level low (right) helped intensify both surface lows.

A Skew-T chart shows a freezing rain setup at work. There’s above-freezing air at 850 to 700 millibars (about 5,000 to 10,000 feet) and subfreezing air below 850 millibars. Any rain falling through the warm layer becomes supercooled and flash-freezes as clear ice on trees, roads—and aircraft. Red line is temperature; green line is dew point; black line is zero celsius.Like the crew of the ore boat’s song, pilots also anticipate the first ice of the winter season with concern. This winter, snow came to the eastern United States relatively early, when winter storm Avery—so dubbed by The Weather Channel—developed November 13 to 14, 2018. (the National Weather Service does not name winter storms.) Avery was created by a large trough aloft, the lifting forces of its associated jet stream winds, and its consequent surface low pressure systems. It was a double-barreled system. In its first phase a surface low affected the Deep South, spreading snow and ice pellets as far south as Louisiana and Mississippi before moving into the Ohio Valley. Then, as the trough and its surface low moved east, it helped form another surface low just north of the Bahamas. This low would prove to be the most influential.

Metars from central Maryland feature truly horrible weather in low IMC. Notice how temperatures and dew points hover around 0 degrees Celsius.The low over the ocean was no tropical depression or hurricane. Sea surface temperatures were too cold for that. Besides, the circulation around this low was open, so it drew in colder air from the north and warmer air to its south, creating the cold and warm fronts that gave it the familiar look of a classic frontal model. In other words, its circulation wasn’t closed like that of a tropical storm or hurricane, so it didn’t have an isolated, “warm core” central area of low pressure.

To the north of this low was a high pressure system. If you think of the flows around highs and lows, you can see how trouble was brewing for the nation’s northeast quadrant. The counterclockwise flow around the oceanic low was bringing warm, moist air north in its warm front. The clockwise flow around the high over southern Ontario, Quebec, and northern New England was sending cold air to the south. The oceanic low’s warm front began riding up and over the cold, dense, sinking air from the northern high as it moved toward the Cape Hatteras area. And while the warm front’s surface location may have been running to the east of the Cape, its shallow slope brought warm air aloft as far north as Pennsylvania and New York state by November 15.

P&E February 2019
Zoomed image
The low-level prog charts for November 15 did a great job of forecasting huge areas of instrument meteorological conditions.

Were there any airmets or sigmets? You better believe it. Moderate icing prevailed in clouds reaching 20,000 feet in layers, moderate or greater turbulence was the rule, and low (ceilings below 500 feet, visibilities below one mile) instrument meteorological conditions in rain, snow, and freezing rain covered much of the mid-Atlantic and Ohio Valley. This whole mess—and it covered entire states—was tracking toward New England.

Temperatures aloft were critical. Remember, with a warm front, warmer air (a relative term) lies over cold. Any precipitation from the warm frontal surface aloft will fall into that colder air. If that colder air is below freezing—and in winter systems, it usually is—then the result is snow, ice pellets, or freezing rain. It all depends on how long the falling precipitation spends in subfreezing temperatures on the way down. If the precipitation is in subfreezing air all the way to the surface, then snowfall occurs.

But what if it falls through layers of warmer, then suddenly subfreezing air? Then snow can melt into ice pellets (aka sleet), graupel (where supercooled water droplets freeze on snowflakes, making snow pellets), or freezing rain. That is exactly what happened with Avery in the mid-Atlantic. In many locations, there was a layer of above-freezing temperatures at 2,000 to 5,000 feet msl, and beneath it a subfreezing layer hugging the surface. This is the classic recipe for freezing rain.

As Avery moved north, the National Weather Service updated significant events through its mesoscale discussions (MDs). There were plenty during this storm’s trip through the eastern United States, and no pilot would want to fly through areas affected by any of them. You can check for any mesoscale discussions at the Storm Prediction Center website. Click on the “SPC Products” dropdown menu, then select Mesoscale Discussions. MDs are worth checking during any preflight briefing—and they are posted all year, not just the winter months. Sure, their text portions include some meteorological jargon, but together with their accompanying chart illustrations they can help you understand storm dynamics. In Avery’s case, after a quick glance at MDs and the Aviation Weather Center’s Current and Forecast Icing Potential charts, you instantly know you should fly another day.

Email [email protected]

P&E February 2019
Zoomed image
MD #1648 (above left) shows a rain-snow line. Snow falls north of the line, where subfreezing air extends to the surface. South of the line, precipitation falls through a warm layer, then re-freezes as a mix of snow, ice pellets and freezing rain. MD #1651 (above right) has the rain-snow line moving north, but a warm layer aloft and a subfreezing layer beneath it remain over southern New England.
Thomas A. Horne
Thomas A. Horne
AOPA Pilot Editor at Large
AOPA Pilot Editor at Large Tom Horne has worked at AOPA since the early 1980s. He began flying in 1975 and has an airline transport pilot and flight instructor certificates. He’s flown everything from ultralights to Gulfstreams and ferried numerous piston airplanes across the Atlantic.

Related Articles